The Godless Megillah

Something to think about for Purim this year

It’s probably one of the most famous questions about the Book of Esther: Why is God not mentioned even once in the entire text? Surely a religious book, part of the Holy Hebrew Bible, should mention God. Quite a few answers have been given to this conundrum. Many focus on the ‘hiddenness’ of God, the word ‘Esther’ literally meaning ‘hidden’. They point out that the events in the Megillah span a whole decade, with no overt miracles at all, implying that it is our challenge to see God’s hand within the story. But I would like to suggest a different approach…

I think the lack of any mention of God in the story is actually part of an even bigger question: Why are there are no gods at all mentioned in the Megillah?! Just think about the central role of other gods in all the festivals that recall our survival or triumph over terrible enemies, and you will see how surprising this is…

In the Pesach story, which we recount on Seder night, God says, “I will pass through the land of Egypt on that night; I will smite all the firstborn in the land of Egypt, from human to beast; and upon all the gods of Egypt I will execute judgments; I am God.” (Exodus 12:12).

In the Chanukah story, King Antiochus IV, “sent an Athenian senator to force the Jews to abandon the customs of their ancestors and no longer live by God’s laws; also to profane the Temple in Jerusalem and dedicate it to Zeus… the altar was covered with profane offerings… [Jews were] forced to partake of the sacrifices….” (2 Maccabees 6:1-7).

One of the foremost reasons for the ruin of the First Temple was the widespread idolatry practiced by our ancestors (Avot 5:10, Yoma 9b), and the demise of the Second Temple began in earnest when the Roman Emperor Caligula had a statute of himself erected in the Holy of Holies and demanded it be worshipped (Josephus, Antiquities 15). Our Sages also tell of Jews choosing martyrdom rather than prostrating before idols during the Hadrianic persecutions (Eichah Rabbah 1:50). So idolatry plays a central role in the story of the destruction of both temples that we recall on Tisha B’Av.

Even Yom Kippur was established as the Day of Forgiveness because it was the day that Moses returned clutching the second tablets of stone (Rashi, Exodus 34:29), indicating that God had pardoned the Children of Israel after the sin of the Golden Calf, about which they had exclaimed, “These are your gods, O Israel.” (Exodus 32:4).

So why is there no mention of Persian gods in the Book of Esther? The Persians did have a religion. Their emperors all venerated ‘Ahuramazda’ who they called ‘the greatest of the gods’, and who became the basis of Zoroastrianism.

There is a Midrash (Esther Rabbah 6:2) that puts Mordechai’s refusal to prostrate before Haman down to the fact that he was wearing an idolatrous medallion. But there is no mention of this in the text and, anyway, Haman was an Amalekite who was detached from Persian religious practise. So my query still stands: Why is the Megillah so godless? Why does Achashverosh make no mention of any gods at the huge feast he threw in his Shushan Palace?

This is especially surprising because the book of Daniel recounts a similar event a few decades earlier when Belshazzar, the last Babylonian Emperor, “made a great feast for a thousand of his lords” (5:1). At that feast, “Belshazzar… commanded to bring the golden and silver utensils which his father Nebuchadnezzar had taken from the Temple which was in Jerusalem; so that the king, and his lords, his wives, and his concubines, might drink from them“ (5:2). According to the Talmud, Achashverosh also displayed utensils from the Temple during his feast (Megillah 11b). Yet at Belshazzar’s feast, “They all drank wine, and praised the gods of gold, and of silver, of bronze, of iron, of wood, and of stone.” (5:4). So why didn’t the Persians? Why is there no mention of sacrifices, worship or any reliance on gods throughout the Megillah?

To answer this I would like to suggest that, although there were religious aspects to the culture of ancient Persia, the Megillah presents it as a distinctly secular society. This understanding is borne out from a well-travelled Greek writer who lived just a few decades after the events of Purim, “The following are Persian customs which I can describe from personal knowledge. The erection of statues, temples, and altars is not accepted practice amongst them, and anyone who does such a thing is considered a fool because, presumably, the Persian religion is not anthropomorphic like the Greek…” (The Histories, Herodotus, Book 1).

It is this that makes Purim the most relevant and modern of all our festivals. It recalls a period in history that has many similarities to our own. Though we live in an ostensibly Christian country, there is little deference to a deity and religious practice is minimal. Almost all public institutions are secular and there is no state-maintained religious coercion of any kind.

We can now understand the surprisingly enduring importance that our Tradition gives to Purim, “All the festivals will lose significance in the days of the Messiah, save for the days of Purim.” (Midrash Mishlei 9:2). This also applies to the Book of Esther itself, “All the Books of Prophets and Writings will be discarded in the future, in the days of the Messiah, with the exception of the Scroll of Esther. It will continue to be valid as will the Five Books of the Torah and the laws of the Oral Torah, which will never be nullified. (Maimonides, Laws of Megillah 2:18).

 The Book of Esther comes at the closing of the Bible. The biblical world was a world full of gods. Worship, sacrifices and other displays of idolatrous devotion were the norm. But as societies progressed and the human intellect developed, a less spiritual and more human-centred culture would gradually arise. And Jews would need to know how to survive in such a culture. The Megillah is a prelude for the modern world.

This then is the lesson of Purim. It teaches us how we can retain religious commitment in a world where God, gods or any religious language hardly gets a mention. It prompts us to remain faithful despite being in a predominantly faithless society.

 

© 2026 London School of Jewish Studies

Registered Charity No. 1131850

Design: Graphical    Development: Beachshore

Website by Beachshore