Korach - The response of Moshe

The most striking thing aspect of Korach’s rebellion, which takes central place in this week’s parasha, is how recognisable it appear in both broad strokes and detail. Worshiping golden calves and complaining about the quality of manna are quite unfamiliar experiences to us as 21st century moderns – community politics, on the other hand, are breath and bread to us. Moreover, the dynamics of the rebellion itself – an aristocratic coup wrapped in egalitarian rhetoric – should be likewise familiar to anyone with a passing awareness of current affairs. But one element which stands at odds with contemporary understanding is Moshe’s response – confronted with a delegation demanding his resignation, he doesn’t answer but rather “fell on his face” – collapsed face-down to the ground.

In order to understand Moshe’s reply we will need to look a little deeper into the story itself. Who were the rebels, and what was their cause? Korach was Moshe’s first cousin and prominent enough to be named individually in the Torah’s account of the Exodus. He joined with 250 men “leaders of the people... men of renown”. And the nature of their complaint? “The whole community is holy... why do you set yourself above us?”. The contradiction of a protest of equality coming solely from those right at the top of the Israelite society is obvious and palpable.

The Talmud subtly picks up this idea in a couple of places, tying the high social position of the rebels directly into their position as collaborators during the period of slavery. Korah was treasurer to Pharoah in Egypt – so wealthy that he needed 300 mules to carry his keys. Datan and Aviram, other rebels mentioned in this parasha, advised Pharoah and rode with him against the Israelites at the Red Sea. The tribal chiefs themselves were the taskmasters and overseers who enforced the slave system upon their extended families. Here then is why Moshe makes no reply to their protest, and offers no argument in favour of his leadership – what response can there be to such a shameless and insincere argument?

This perhaps also explains the spectacular nature of Moshe’s vindication. For earlier crises – the spies, the Golden Calf – resolution came in a direct and individual communication from God, granting forgiveness and doling out punishment through plague or other physical phenomena. There, where the offense was between human and divine, Moshe’s position as intermediary between the two was appropriate. But here when the rebellion was a political one aimed primarily at Moshe’s position as leader, such as response would not have helped and the core threat to his legitimacy would have remained. Only a clear and public demonstration – wrought in fire from heaven – would suffice.

Hypocrisy, we are told, “is the homage vice pays to virtue”, the affirmation of morality in the midst of attempts to negate it. It’s a natural enough part of human nature and society, ranging from the basic politeness towards people we dislike to politicians’ professions of sincerity over focus-grouped positions staked out ten minutes previously. But there are some places where the disjoint between reality and rhetoric is so large, and so self-serving, that we shouldn’t be hypocrites about hypocrisy itself. Sometimes the only response to an outrageous argument is incredulous silence

 

First printed on Limmud on one leg

© 2026 London School of Jewish Studies

Registered Charity No. 1131850

Design: Graphical    Development: Beachshore

Website by Beachshore